Jeff Weintraub has compiled a very useful list of rebuttals to the "Israel Lobby" paper by two prominent "realist" academics, John Mearsheimer of the University of Chicago and Stephen Walt. Here's his list.
================
Jeffrey Herf & Andrei Markovits, Letter to the London Review of Books | LRB (Vol. 28, #7) dated April 6, 2006 [also here]================
Martin Kramer, "Stephen Walt's World" | Sandstorm - March 17, 2006
Lee Smith, "A Place Called Saudi Arabia" | Michael J. Totten's Middle East Journal - March 20, 2006
Richard Baehr & Ed Lasky, "Stephen Walt's War with Israel" | American Thinker - March 20, 2006
Robert Fine, "The Lobby: Mearsheimer and Walt's Conspiracy Theory" | Engage - March 21, 2006
David Hirsh, "The Blame Game" | Guardian "Comment is Free" blog - March 21, 2006
Rick Richman, "Walt, Mearsheimer, and Academic Malpractice" | Jewish Current Issues - March 22, 2006
Shalom Lappin, "More on Mearsheimer and Walt" | Normblog - March 22, 2006
Ruth R. Wisse, "Harvard attack on 'Israel lobby' is actually a targeting of American public" | Jewish World Review - March 23, 2006
Forward Editorial, "In Dark Times, Blame the Jews" | Forward - March 24, 2006
Brian Marcus, "Mearsheimer and Walt's Anti-Israel Screed: A Relentless Assault in Scholarly Guise" (ADL Analysis) | Anti-Defamation League - March 24, 2006
Ami Isseroff, "The Israel Lobby Revisited" | Zionism & Israel Web Log - March 26, 2006
Christopher Hitchens, "Overstating Jewish Power" | Slate.com - March 27, 2006
Noam Chomsky, "The Israel Lobby" | ZNet - March 28, 2006
Joseph Massad, "Blaming the Lobby" | Al Ahram Weekly On-line (#787) March 23-29, 2006
Max Boot, "Policy analysis -- paranoid style" | Los Angeles Times - March 29, 2006
Richard L. Cravatts, "The Paranoid View of History Infects Harvard" | History News Network - April 3, 2006
Eliot A. Cohen, "Yes, It's Anti-Semitic" | Washington Post - April 5, 2006
Alan Dershowitz, "Debunking the Newest--and Oldest--Jewish Conspiracy: A Reply to the Mearsheimer-Walt 'Working Paper'" | Harvard Faculty Responses to KSG Working Papers - April 5, 2006
Dov Waxman, "'The Israel Lobby"--Finally a Balanced Review" | The Globalist - April 6, 2006
Dov Waxman, "The Israel Lobby--Preserving an All-Around Perspective" | The Globalist - April 7, 2006
Steven Zunes, "The US Invasion of Iraq: Not the Fault of Israel and Its Supporters" | Foreign Policy in Focus - January 4, 2006
A couple of additional rebuttals that look worthwhile to me.
Jeremy Schreiber's longish blog entry
and a follow-up
Richard L. Cravatts "The Paranoid View of History Infects Harvard" History News Network
No comments:
Post a Comment